The term musical form is used in two
related ways:
- a generic type of composition such as the
symphony or
concerto
- the structure of a particular piece, how its
parts are put together to make the whole; this too can be
generic, such as
binary form or
sonata form
Musical
form (the whole or structure) is
contrasted with content (the parts) or with
surface (the detail), but there
is no clear line between the two. In most cases, the form of a
piece should produce a balance between
statement and
restatement,
unity and
variety,
contrast and
connection.
There is some overlap between musical form
and
musical genre. The latter
term is more likely to be used when referring to particular styles
of music (such as
classical music or
rock music) as determined by
things such as
harmonic language, typical
rhythms, types of
musical instrument used and
geographical origin. The phrase musical form is typically
used when talking about a particular type or structure within
those genres. For example, the
twelve bar blues is a specific
form often found in the genres of
blues and
rock and roll music.
Forms and formal detail may be described as
sectional or developmental, developmental or variational,
syntactical or processual (Keil 1966), embodied or engendered,
extensional or intensional (Chester 1970), and associational or
hierarchical (Lerdahl 1983). Form may also be described according
to symmetries or lack thereof and repetition. A common idea is
formal "depth", necessary for complexity, in which foregrounded
"detail" events occur against a more structural background. For
example:
Schenkerian analysis.
Fred Lerdahl (1992), among
others, claims that popular music lacks the structural complexity
for multiple structural layers, and thus much depth. However,
Lerdahl's theories explicitly exclude "associational" details
which are used to help articulate form in popular music.
Allen Forte's book The
American Popular Ballad of the Golden Era 1924-1950 analyses
popular music with traditional Schenkerian techniques, but this is
only possible because pre-rock popular
ballads are the genre most
accessible similar to the
Romantic music that those
theories were designed to analyse. (Middleton 1999, p.144)
Extensional music is, "produced by starting with
small components - rhythmic or melodic motifs, perhaps - and then
'developing' these through techniques of modification and
combination." Intensional music "starts with a framework - a chord
sequence, a melodic outline, a rhythmic pattern - and then extends
itself by repeating the framework with perpetually varied
inflections to the details filling it in." (Middleton, p.142)
- Western classical music is the apodigm of the
extensional form of musical construction. Theme and
variations, counterpoint, tonality (as used in classical
composition) are all devices that build diachronically and
synchronically outwards from basic musical atoms. The complex is
created by combination of the simple, which remains discrete and
unchanged in the complex unity...If those critics who maintain
the greater complexity of classical music specified that they
had in mind this extensional development, they would be
quite correct...Rock however follows, like many non-European
musics, the path of intensional development. In this mode of
construction the basic musical units (played/sung notes) are not
combined through space and time as simple elements into complex
structures. The simple entity is that constituted by the
parameters of melody, harmony, and beat, while the complex is
built up by modulation of the basic notes, and by inflexion of
the basic beat. All existing genres and sub-types of the
Afro-American tradition show various forms of combined
intensional and extensional development (Chester 1970, p.78-9).
Syntactic music is "centres" on notation and
"the hierarchic organization of quasilinguistic elements and their
putting together (com-position) in line with systems of norms,
expectations, surprises, tensions and resolutions. The resulting
aesthetic is one of 'embodied meaning.'" Non-notated music and
performance "foreground process. They are much more
concerned with gesture, physical feel, the immediate moment,
improvisation; the resulting aesthetic is one of 'engendered
feeling' and is unsuited to the application of 'syntactice'
criteria" (Middleton 1990, p.115).
Middleton (p.145) also describes form,
presumably after
Gilles Deleuze’s Difference
and Repetition (1968, translated 1994), through
repetition and
difference. Difference is the
distance moved from a repeat and a repeat being the smallest
difference. Difference is qualitative and quantitative, how far
different and what type of difference.
In
classical and
popular music, there are many
labels applied to forms, abstract formal designs, as contrasted
with the principals and procedures of combining materials: form.
Typical structures used to shape a single movement include:
In a sectional form, the larger unit
(form) is built from various smaller clear-cut units (sections) in
combination, sort of like stacking legos (DeLone, 1975):
Sections
include:
Developmental
forms, larger unit (form) is built from small bits of material
given different presentations and combinations, usually
progressive (DeLone, 1975):
Variational
forms, larger unit (form) is built from sections treated to one
type of presentation at a time, but varying succesively (DeLone,
1975):
These structures are defined by the distribution
of different thematic material,
melodies,
key centres, and other materials
used. While many of the above forms are partly defined by their
tonal schemes these forms may be
applied to music which has a differing or no tonal scheme (DeLone
et. al. (Eds.), 1975, chap. 1). More than one formal method may be
used, including in-between types, and music which is not composed
with the above or any other model is called
through composed.
Especially recently, more segmented approaches
have been taken through the use of
stratification,
superimposition,
juxtaposition,
interpolation, and other
interruptions and
simultaneities. Examples include
the postmodern "block"
technique used by composers such as
John Zorn, where rather than
organic development one follows separate units in various
combinations. These techniques may be used to create contrast to
the point of disjointed chaotic textures, or, through repetition
and return and
transitional procedures such as
dissolution,
amalgamation, and
gradation, may create
connectedness and unity.
Composers have also made more use of
open forms such as produced by
aleatoric devices and other
chance procedures,
improvisation, and some
processes. (ibid)
Types of piece which may or may not incorporate
one or more of the above structures as part of their overall
makeup include:
Forms of
chamber music are defined by
instrumentation (string
quartet,
piano quintet and so on). The
structure of a chamber work is typically similar to a sonata.
See also